ShellProven
Lesson 09 · tested on Debian 13

Cron job not running? It works in the terminal, here's why it fails in cron

A script runs fine when you type it, but does nothing from cron. Using a real cron daemon, this video logs the job's output to see the actual error, dumps cron's environment to show its tiny PATH and different working directory, fixes both in the crontab, and explains the percent-sign trap that silently breaks date commands in cron.

Video coming soon — @ShellProven

Commands

Exactly as run in the video. Full folder with setup script and log: terminal-tutorials/cron-not-running.

# A script that works
$ cat backup.sh
#!/bin/sh
report-tool > report.txt
echo "saved report"
$ ./backup.sh && cat report.txt
saved report
report for demo: 42 orders

# Schedule it, and log the output
$ cat first.cron
# min hour day month weekday  command
* * * * * /lab/jobs/backup.sh >> /tmp/backup.log 2>&1
* * * * * env > /tmp/cron-env.txt
$ crontab first.cron && crontab -l
# min hour day month weekday  command
* * * * * /lab/jobs/backup.sh >> /tmp/backup.log 2>&1
* * * * * env > /tmp/cron-env.txt

# Why it fails
$ cat /tmp/backup.log
/lab/jobs/backup.sh: 2: report-tool: not found
saved report
$ cat /tmp/cron-env.txt
HOME=/root
LOGNAME=root
PATH=/usr/bin:/bin
SHELL=/bin/sh
PWD=/root
$ ls /root
report.txt

# The fix: PATH and cd in the crontab
$ cat fixed.cron
PATH=/usr/local/bin:/usr/bin:/bin
# min hour day month weekday  command
* * * * * cd /lab/jobs && ./backup.sh >> /tmp/backup.log 2>&1
* * * * * echo "ran at $(date +%H:%M)" >> /tmp/broken.log
* * * * * echo "ran at $(date +\%H:\%M)" >> /tmp/fixed.log
$ crontab fixed.cron

# Check it
$ tail -n 1 /tmp/backup.log && cat report.txt
saved report
report for demo: 42 orders

# The percent-sign trap
$ cat /tmp/broken.log
cat: /tmp/broken.log: No such file or directory
$ cat /tmp/fixed.log
ran at 20:08

Quick check

Same two questions as in the video. Checked here, in your browser — nothing is sent anywhere.

Transparency. Script and narration made with AI, human-reviewed. The robot and the dog are AI-generated cartoon characters. The commands and their output are real runs in a container.